Sandip Roy
Sandip Roy is an editor with New America Media and host of its radio show New America Now on KALW 91.7  FM.
The Persians are Coming

The Persians are coming. I don’t know too much about the Battle of Thermopylae and I haven’t read the Frank Miller graphic novel but the overriding message of the film 300 was “The Persians are coming” and only 300 brave Spartans stand in the way. Given the timing of the movie, it felt a little like an ROTC ad for the Marines – the few, the brave, the fast, the furious.

The other overriding message is the Persians are gay. The Spartans are kind of gay too in a homophobic, “we are not boy lovers” way. Or as homophobic as you can be when your entire army’s battle uniform is hot pants and cape, so you can just bludgeon the enemy with your abs. (And to think some Marines or reservists got into trouble for posing nude for some magazine.)When the Spartan king clashes with the Persian emperor Xerxes it’s meant to be the clash of civilizations. It feels more like a bar brawl between two gay fashion statements – muscle bear without body hair vs effete sissies with lots of piercings. No prizes for guessing who is what. Here’s a hint – when a weapon flies close to Xerxes’ face, his hand flutters in front of him in a “Not-the-face” kinda way. Only the hard and strong may call themselves Spartan. Umm that sounds like an ad for a gay porn site actually.

Xerxes Gerard Butler

Once you’ve gotten over the gay Jets and Sharks having a rumble in Sparta, 300 is a very topical film. First everyone with a turban is evil and should be tossed off a cliff or into a deep hole, even the ones who are just messengers not soldiers. If President Ahmadinejad writes any more letters, I think after 300 no one is going to deliver them.

More contemporary parallels – there is a coalition of the willing here too. And like the current one it’s pretty measly as well. Untrustworthy Brits, I mean Spanish, I mean Arcadians who desert the Americans, I mean the Spartans, when the going gets tough. Meanwhile the cowering Congress doesn’t realize “Freedom isn’t free at all. It comes with the highest of prices. Blood.” Wasn’t that in the State of Union speech before the last Presidential election?

Spartan blood is a small price to pay we are reminded against “Asia’s endless hordes.” And the endless hordes had better watch out – “Spartans never retreat, Spartans never surrender.”

The 300 brave Spartans and their hotpants are the only things that stand between civilization and “the barbarians.” And they make a promise to the world – “we will rescue the world from mysticism and tyranny.”

And they do all this with just 300 hard and strong men. (The movie was obviously made before Donald Rumsfeld got the boot). But if 300 can hold back the Persian masses surely the surge of 21,500 more soldiers can do the job in Iraq. Except here’s the one small problem – in the Battle of Thermopylae, the 300 Spartans were defending their home against the swarming barbarian Persian hordes at their gates. The 21,500 new American troops in the Middle East are the ones doing the surging at the gates of Persia.

Pesky details – on the plus side I am hoping the DVD will include the “Get Spartan Abs in 300 Days Killer Workout.”


comments

  1. I thought the film also had a modern day twist with it as well in terms of war and honor.

    By Cynical ·  Posted on Mar 13, 01:09 PM
  2. Sounds like your looking for a reason to rant about some political injustice so bad that you totally ignored the fact that this is loosly based off a true story. Most of the movie details correlate with historic details, granted the main difference is that Leonytis was allowed to take 300 men. Most of the other details were exagerated upon or embelished for the movie but remain primarily true. Many of the lines in the movie were taken from actual history and save for minor details, they nailed the story as well as hollywood can these days. And in all actuality you could more compare america today with the persians than the spartans, granted America’s religious beliefs differ from both nations. So before you go making this about your poor life in your tyranical war-mongering dictator led country, read the story behind the movie. I’m pretty sure your opinion might change.

    By Jo ·  Posted on Mar 20, 01:20 PM
  3. Jo, Where did you learn history?

    The only historical facts that this movie “loosly” adhered to (as you suggested) are that a Battle of Thermopylae, occured, Leonidas and Xerxes, were real kings who duked it out.

    The rest is the imagination of one man with his own particular world view and politics. His name is Frank Miller and the movie is based on a graphic novel. What you saw in the movie came out of Frank’s imagination with further input and interpretation from the director and whatever other fantastically juvenile minds worked on the movie.

    No, there is no comparison between America of today and the Persians lead by Xerxes II. If you would like to know why I can only suggest more studying on your part.

    What do religious beliefs have to do with your view that one could potentially draw parallels between the Persians and America?

    You are obviously familiar with the “story” behind the movie. You might want to study some “history” as well.

    By J Rice ·  Posted on Jul 31, 02:06 PM
  4. lmao 300 was utter rubbish the only vaguely interesting part was when that sexy stelios was on screen & because i fancy the hot pants off him did i watch this totally racist film:-p. anyone else notice how ugly the persians were made out to be? now i know spartans were tough but come-on! this film deservedly got trashed. as for the american war on iraq we all know it’s for securing oil & not a damn thing will convince me otherwise, nuclear weapons my ass :-s

    By Sara ·  Posted on Aug 4, 04:22 PM
  5. Nice writing. You are on my RSS reader now so I can read more from you down the road.

    By Alan ·  Posted on Aug 24, 05:19 AM
  add comment:  
  Textile Help
« previous entry next entry »